In
Orthodoxy and me, Mr. Rod Dreher, the
Crunchy Con, informs us that he has swum the Bosporus: "I am now a communicant of the Orthodox Church, and have been (along with my family) for a couple of months." Although he writes and has written about the
Sex Abuse Scandal in great detail, he insists that this was not his reason for separating himself from the Catholic Church, but rather his inability to accept
Papal Infallibility. One cannot help but think that this stumbling block was one he must have crossed when he converted to Catholicism from Protestantism over a decade ago, but if this is indeed his reason, one cannot help but wish him the best. At the very least, this is a more charitable approach than wishing him "Good riddance, schismo!"
[Back in May, when
Rod Dreher Read My Blog, it had its
Busiest Day Ever. In a post entitled
Blogosphere on Style section, Mr. Dreher responded to my criticism of his flirtation with the East in a post of mine entitled
Rod Dreher hits the WaPo.]
Moving in the opposite direction, and back a century earlier,
Traditional Catholic Reflections & Reports today posts
Soloviev's View of the Mission of the Universal Church. The great Russian Catholic notes that Eastern Christians "are not asked to change [their] nature as Easterns or to repudiate the specific character of [their] religious genius" but "only to recognize unreservedly the elementary truth that we of the East are but a part of the Universal Church, a part moreover which has not its center within itself, and that therefore it behooves us to restore the link between our individual forces upon the circumference and the great universal center which Providence has placed in the West."
Soloviev's critique of the East's "exclusive asceticism" reminds me of the injunction from the Gospel to "be
in the world, but not
of the world." The East errs in overemphasizing the latter at the expense of the former, while the West makes the opposite error, bringing about horrors such as the heresy of
Amercanism and the resulting Gay Priest Scandal.
May Catholics strive to be orthodox and Orthodox catholic!
Schism is painful and scandalous, so let us work toward the realization of the vision of
Vladimir Sergeevich Soloviev on the Antichrist, in which "Pope Peter II, John the Elder, leader of the Orthodox and Professor Ernst Pauli, representing Protestantism" unite in the end.
Ut unum sint.